Hello, Everyone.
I try to using Haiku in Chatreey AN2P 5625u.
It is not bad machine. But It cannot play any sound.
So, I searched some articles in this forum. and I installed open sound system. but nothing is happen.
I suppouse that open sound system does not support radeon. is it true?
I don’t know what can I do.
Open sound is a solution for old hardware. It is still there because it allows to make old (proprietary) drivers that were available for BeOS work . But really, development has stopped for 15 years now.
So, it is definitely not an option in your case. Better remove opensound package and blacklist entries.
On modern hardware, either your ‘card’ is supported by Haiku HDA driver or you should fill an enhancement ticket on Haiku bug tracker Trac.
Buy a cheap USB-Audio Sound stick…
USB audio chip ?
In Teminal
listusb
0573:1573 /dev/bus/usb/1/2 “Zoran Co. Personal Media Division (Nogatech)” “USB Audio and HID” ver. 8007
Here it is.
It is probably a USB 2.0 device, which the current USB Audio driver prevents from Initializing.
It is confusing… there is USB Audio codec 1.0, and 2.0. And then there is USB 1.1, and USB 2.0, USB 3.0 interfaces, etc.
The Haiku USB Audio driver currently only supports the USB Audio codec 1.0, and it intends to block initialization for USB Audio codec 2.0. But the driver blocks any audio device using USB 2.0 interface.
So that device, probably is a USB Audio codec 1.0, but reports itself as using a USB 2.0 interface, which our driver blocks it from initializing expecting it to be incompatible.
More information would be given if you did a:
listusb -v
[Device /dev/bus/usb/1/2]
Class .................. 0x00 (Defined at Interface level) ()
Subclass ............... 0x00 (Defined at Interface level) ()
Protocol ............... 0x00 (Defined at Interface level) ()
Max Endpoint 0 Packet .. 64
USB Version ............ 2.0
Vendor ID .............. 0x0573 (Zoran Co. Personal Media Division (Nogatech))
Product ID ............. 0x1573
Product Version ........ 0x8007
Manufacturer String .... "CSCTEK"
Product String ......... "USB Audio and HID"
Serial Number .......... "A34004801402"
[Configuration 0]
Configuration String . ""
[Interface 0]
[Alternate 0 active]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x01 Audio (Control Device)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Control Device)
Interface String ... ""
[Descriptor 0]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x01 (Header)
ADC Release ....... 1.0
Total Length ...... 70
Interfaces ........ 1, 2,
[Descriptor 1]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x02 (Input Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 1
Terminal Type ..... 0x0101 (USB Streaming)
Associated Terminal 0
Nr Channels ....... 2
Channel Config .... 0x3
Front .......... Left Right
Channel Names ..... 0
Terminal .......... 0
[Descriptor 2]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x06 (Feature Unit)
Unit ID ........... 5
Source ID ......... 4
Control Size ...... 1
Master Channel . Mute Volume
Feature ........... 0
[Descriptor 3]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x03 (Output Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 2
Terminal Type ..... 0x0101 (USB Streaming)
Associated Terminal 0
Source ID ......... 5
Terminal .......... 0
[Descriptor 4]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x06 (Feature Unit)
Unit ID ........... 6
Source ID ......... 1
Control Size ...... 1
Master Channel . Mute
Channel 1 ...... Volume
Channel 2 ...... Volume
Feature ........... 0
[Descriptor 5]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x03 (Output Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 3
Terminal Type ..... 0x0301 (Speaker)
Associated Terminal 0
Source ID ......... 6
Terminal .......... 0
[Descriptor 6]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x02 (Input Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 4
Terminal Type ..... 0x0201 (Microphone)
Associated Terminal 0
Nr Channels ....... 1
Channel Config .... 0x1
Front .......... Left
Channel Names ..... 0
Terminal .......... 0
[Interface 1]
[Alternate 0 active]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Alternate 1]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Endpoint 0]
MaxPacketSize .... 1x 100 bytes
Interval ......... 1
Type ............. Isochronous
Direction ........ Input
[Descriptor 0]
Subtype ........... 1 (AS_GENERAL)
Terminal link ..... 2
Delay ............. 1
Format tag ........ 1
[Descriptor 1]
Subtype ........... 2 (FORMAT_TYPE)
Format Type ....... 1 (FORMAT_TYPE_I)
Channels .......... 1
Subframe size ..... 2
Bit resolution .... 16
Sampling Freq ..... 8000, 16000, 48000,
[Descriptor 2]
Type .............. 0x25 (CS_ENDPOINT)
Subtype ........... 0x01 (EP_GENERAL)
Attributes ........ 0x01 Sampling Frequency
Lock Delay Units .. 0 (Undefined)
Lock Delay ........ 0
[Interface 2]
[Alternate 0 active]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Alternate 1]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Endpoint 0]
MaxPacketSize .... 1x 192 bytes
Interval ......... 1
Type ............. Isochronous
Direction ........ Output
[Descriptor 0]
Subtype ........... 1 (AS_GENERAL)
Terminal link ..... 1
Delay ............. 1
Format tag ........ 1
[Descriptor 1]
Subtype ........... 2 (FORMAT_TYPE)
Format Type ....... 1 (FORMAT_TYPE_I)
Channels .......... 2
Subframe size ..... 2
Bit resolution .... 16
Sampling Freq ..... 8000, 16000, 48000,
[Descriptor 2]
Type .............. 0x25 (CS_ENDPOINT)
Subtype ........... 0x01 (EP_GENERAL)
Attributes ........ 0x01 Sampling Frequency
Lock Delay Units .. 0 (Undefined)
Lock Delay ........ 0
[Interface 3]
[Alternate 0 active]
Class .............. 0x03 Human Interface Device (No Subclass, None)
Subclass ........... 0x00 Human Interface Device (No Subclass, None)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Human Interface Device (No Subclass, None)
Interface String ... ""
[Endpoint 0]
MaxPacketSize .... 1x 64 bytes
Interval ......... 1
Type ............. Interrupt
Direction ........ Output
[Descriptor 0]
Length............ 0x09
Type ............. 0x21
Data ............. 10 01 00 01 22 1b 00
Here it is.
and I bought a usb sound stick. Haiku recognized that. but cannot output any sound. I think that it is not matched with Haiku. I’ll search for other usb sound stick.
Looks like you already have two tickets for enhancement to fill, one for the Realtek chipset and another for this device. Don’t forget to add a link to this thread.
Sorry. I don’t know what ticket is and How to use ticket.
Is there some kind of document I should read?
Yes, here. Welcome to Haiku!
Yes, the USB ADC codec is 1.0, but the USB Version is 2.0. It should work in theory with our driver. Since it is USB Version 2.0, it is blocked. It would be interesting to see if it would work.
https://dev.haiku-os.org/ticket/18320
[Device /dev/bus/usb/1/0]
Class .................. 0x00 (Defined at Interface level) ()
Subclass ............... 0x00 (Defined at Interface level) ()
Protocol ............... 0x00 (Defined at Interface level) ()
Max Endpoint 0 Packet .. 8
USB Version ............ 1.16
Vendor ID .............. 0x08bb (Texas Instruments)
Product ID ............. 0x2902 (PCM2902 Audio Codec)
Product Version ........ 0x0100
Manufacturer String .... "C-Media Electronics Inc. "
Product String ......... "USB PnP Sound Device"
Serial Number .......... ""
[Configuration 0]
Configuration String . ""
[Interface 0]
[Alternate 0 active]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x01 Audio (Control Device)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Control Device)
Interface String ... ""
[Descriptor 0]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x01 (Header)
ADC Release ....... 1.0
Total Length ...... 100
Interfaces ........ 1, 2,
[Descriptor 1]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x02 (Input Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 1
Terminal Type ..... 0x0101 (USB Streaming)
Associated Terminal 0
Nr Channels ....... 2
Channel Config .... 0x3
Front .......... Left Right
Channel Names ..... 0
Terminal .......... 0
[Descriptor 2]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x02 (Input Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 2
Terminal Type ..... 0x0201 (Microphone)
Associated Terminal 0
Nr Channels ....... 1
Channel Config .... 0x1
Front .......... Left
Channel Names ..... 0
Terminal .......... 0
[Descriptor 3]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x03 (Output Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 6
Terminal Type ..... 0x0301 (Speaker)
Associated Terminal 0
Source ID ......... 9
Terminal .......... 0
[Descriptor 4]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x03 (Output Terminal)
Terminal ID ....... 7
Terminal Type ..... 0x0101 (USB Streaming)
Associated Terminal 0
Source ID ......... 8
Terminal .......... 0
[Descriptor 5]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x05 (Selector Unit)
Unit ID ........... 8
Source IDs ........ 10,
Selector .......... 10
[Descriptor 6]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x06 (Feature Unit)
Unit ID ........... 9
Source ID ......... 15
Control Size ...... 1
Master Channel . Mute
Channel 1 ...... Volume
Channel 2 ...... Volume
Feature ........... 0
[Descriptor 7]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x06 (Feature Unit)
Unit ID ........... 10
Source ID ......... 2
Control Size ...... 1
Master Channel . Mute Volume Automatic Gain
Feature ........... 0
[Descriptor 8]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x06 (Feature Unit)
Unit ID ........... 13
Source ID ......... 2
Control Size ...... 1
Master Channel . Mute Volume
Feature ........... 0
[Descriptor 9]
Type .............. 0x24
Subtype ........... 0x04 (Mixer Unit)
Unit ID ........... 15
Source IDs ........ 1, 13,
Channels .......... 2
Channel Config .... 0x3
Front .......... Left Right
Channel Names ..... 0
Bitmap Control .... 0x00
Mixer ............. 0
[Interface 1]
[Alternate 0]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Alternate 1 active]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Endpoint 0]
MaxPacketSize .... 1x 200 bytes
Interval ......... 1
Type ............. Isochronous
Direction ........ Output
[Descriptor 0]
Subtype ........... 1 (AS_GENERAL)
Terminal link ..... 1
Delay ............. 1
Format tag ........ 1
[Descriptor 1]
Subtype ........... 2 (FORMAT_TYPE)
Format Type ....... 1 (FORMAT_TYPE_I)
Channels .......... 2
Subframe size ..... 2
Bit resolution .... 16
Sampling Freq ..... 48000, 44100,
[Descriptor 2]
Type .............. 0x25 (CS_ENDPOINT)
Subtype ........... 0x01 (EP_GENERAL)
Attributes ........ 0x01 Sampling Frequency
Lock Delay Units .. 1 (Milliseconds)
Lock Delay ........ 1
[Interface 2]
[Alternate 0]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Alternate 1 active]
Class .............. 0x01 Audio ()
Subclass ........... 0x02 Audio (Streaming)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Audio (Streaming)
Interface String ... ""
[Endpoint 0]
MaxPacketSize .... 1x 100 bytes
Interval ......... 1
Type ............. Isochronous
Direction ........ Input
[Descriptor 0]
Subtype ........... 1 (AS_GENERAL)
Terminal link ..... 7
Delay ............. 1
Format tag ........ 1
[Descriptor 1]
Subtype ........... 2 (FORMAT_TYPE)
Format Type ....... 1 (FORMAT_TYPE_I)
Channels .......... 1
Subframe size ..... 2
Bit resolution .... 16
Sampling Freq ..... 48000, 44100,
[Descriptor 2]
Type .............. 0x25 (CS_ENDPOINT)
Subtype ........... 0x01 (EP_GENERAL)
Attributes ........ 0x01 Sampling Frequency
Lock Delay Units .. 0 (Undefined)
Lock Delay ........ 0
[Interface 3]
[Alternate 0 active]
Class .............. 0x03 Human Interface Device (No Subclass, None)
Subclass ........... 0x00 Human Interface Device (No Subclass, None)
Protocol ........... 0x00 Human Interface Device (No Subclass, None)
Interface String ... ""
[Endpoint 0]
MaxPacketSize .... 1x 4 bytes
Interval ......... 2
Type ............. Interrupt
Direction ........ Input
[Descriptor 0]
Length............ 0x09
Type ............. 0x21
Data ............. 00 01 00 01 22 3c 00
I bought a new usb sound stick. Haiku recognized that. but It cannot play any sound. very interesting.
xHCI Host Controller USB 3.1 and USB 3.2 - not supported usb_audio driver.
USB 3.0/2.0 work fine.
This time, I bought three usb sound sticks as cheap as possible, but when I connected the three one by one and booted Haiku, media_addon_server crashed. I don’t know if all three devices are strange or if something else is needed.
If someone were use a usb sound stick, Can you recommand that?
As mentioned before, have you already removed OpenSound and blacklisted it ?
I have tested an Audio Technica ATR2x-USB with Haiku when USB Audio support was fixed recently and it works fine. I just tested it again with the latest nightly and it still works. If it’s not detected initially, you may need to click ‘Restart Media Services’ in the Media preferences for it to come up. With this particular adapter though it seems to be detected fine on boot. Link to the adapter here, it’s readily available to purchase online and not too expensive: https://www.audio-technica.com/en-au/3-5-mm-to-usb-digital-audio-adapter
Unfortunately having a working adapter won’t change anything, if like stated kim1963 usb_audio is not working on XHCI 3.2. Probably some that dsscrolls already bought would work fine on another machine.
So better try to make the internal Radeon Renoir chipset work. But one thing is certain, if there are no bug report for non-working devices, support for them won’t appear magically.
Yes that appears to be the issue given multiple the likely compliant devices that have been purchased do not work. Which would be easier to implement in this instance though, adding USB 3.2 support or supporting the internal audio chipset?